5Church Opens in Atlanta: First Impressions

If you visited Shout before it closed, you’ll do a double take when you see the sexy new decor at 5Church. Hailing from Charlotte, NC, 5Church is very particular about the decor in their restaurants. The artist hired to paint the ceiling spent two and a half months painstakingly working away to create what you see below.


An artist spent two and a half months painting the ceiling at 5Church.

Although decor isn’t exactly the same from one restaurant to another, 5Church is very big on the black and white color scheme owner, Ayman Kamel, told me when I visited 5Church last month.  All lighting fixtures are imported from Europe. Special feathered lights loom over the bar, while the dome shaped lamps have a beautiful leaf pattern stamped inside. The black leather booths and chairs are comfy. So comfy, in fact, you may find it hard to get up after a filling meal and several glasses of wine.  I appreciate that 5Church provides ample spacing from table to table, enabling a fair amount of private conversations with your dining companions.


L: Pigtail Croquettes, R: House made Buratta with spiced honey and basil

The menu is divided into Snacks, First Course, Main Course and Steaks. Buratta with spiced honey was bursting with floral notes. Pastrami cured hamachi was the most unique dish that evening. Paired with red mole, radishes, limes and corn nuts, I’d call it seafood charcuterie. Listed under the First Course, it is good to balance out the Heirloom Tomato Salad (pictured below).

5-church-atlanta-restaurant review

Heirloom tomato and pickled watermelon salad

However, I loved the Squid Ink calamari with generous portions of both calamari and lump crab. If you are a crab fan, besides a luscious squid ink dish, the  Lump Crab was incredible and pairing it with seaweed was a fantastic touch. First Course plates at 5Chruch average around $13 each. Three or four will do for a meal and you’ll leave feeling like you’ve really explored the menu without dropping a ton of cash.


Squid Ink Tagliatelle with Crab and Calamari

Menu items are rather diverse as well. Besides a lamb burger, there’s scallops, Whole Roasted Fish (see below), smoked duck and of course, the signature Wagyu steak. It’s lovely and certain stands up to the best steaks you’ll find in Atlanta, but a 4 oz cut (the minimum you can get) is $60. It’s Wagyu, so it’s priced accordingly.


Redfish at 5Church in Midtown

Wholefish was incredible. Beyond the beautiful presentation, the Redfish was prepared perfectly. And certainly something a group could share, with several small plates to begin, this would round out a meal nicely.


Peanut Butter & Jelly Dessert at 5Church

Dessert at 5Church isnn’t to be overlooked as they put as much effort into sweets as other sections of the menu. A Peanut Butter and Jelly had a layers of chocolate and peanut butter, plus was topped with crushed peanuts, sea salt and a layer of dark chocolate. Small circles of grape jelly were sprinkled around the dish.

Twisted Chocolate with pistachio and raspberry was quite interesting. The chocolate, extruded to form the snake figure, was creamy and soft. I loved the presentation of the deconstructed dessert with powdered pistachio and chocolate. Perfect for sharing with your table mates, everyone can have their own perfect bite, adding a little or a lot of pistachio, raspberry and additional chocolate.


Chocolate Dessert

After what seems like a long hiatus, it is nice to see a restaurant taking over the Shout space. Though 5Church has not opened the patio yet as they are still working on the design, I know many are anxious to get out there as we transition to fall weather.

1197 Peachtree St NE #528
Atlanta, GA 30361


Malika is the author of several books including Culinary Atlanta: Guide to the Best Restaurants, Markets, Breweries and More! and the founder of Roamilicious. She is also a Digital Marketing and Social Media Consultant. Follow us @Roamilicious on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and Pinterest for the content not shared on the blog. And don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter (subscribe box below) and never miss a contest, giveaway or the latest must visit restaurant!